Don't be fooled by how small this place looks, they have the best selection of fine spirits in town. They definitely don't carry everything under the sun, but they do carry what you actually want.
Feel free to ask the staff for recommendations, they all seem to be well versed in what they carry.
Half the store is wine, and the other half is about 50/50 beer and spirits. It's my go-to liquor store in Laramie.